A misleading code: Finding the right solution to the right problem

A misleading code: Finding the right solution to the right problem

In having the privilege of presenting at Worldpac’s Supplier and Training Expo in Orlando Florida earlier this year, I met a couple of instructors from the Daytona State College who attended my seminar: Beau Bosman and Casey Knecht. During my presentation, I covered an issue with an Allison 1000/2000 that had the converter clutch cycling on and off. The crank sensor is mounted on the converter housing which receives its signal from the protrusions on the converter where the internal fins mount. One of these protrusions was flattened causing a loss of one pulse per each revolution of the converter. This consistent rhythmic pulse loss caused the computer to cycle the converter on and off. I then showed a picture of another converter where someone had decided to add a drain plug in between two of these protrusions. This caused an additional signal to be added to each revolution of the converter.

On this same topic, Beau shared with me an interesting problem he had with a vehicle he purchased. It was a 1999 Dodge Ram 1500 5.9L 4×4 with 283,000 miles. This is what he wrote:

I was able to buy the vehicle for $300 as it was about to go to the salvage yard to be laid to rest. The previous owner claimed the transmission had problems and so it sat for about a year before he decided to get rid of it.

Once the vehicle was towed to my garage, I charged the battery and started the vehicle. It idled fine in both park and all drive ranges. I then checked the transmission fluid, and it was found to be full and clean. Getting into the vehicle, when I raised the engine RPM to approximately 1200-1400 while in park, the vehicle started to misfire badly on multiple cylinders illuminating the check engine light.

A scan tool pulled code P1391 for an Intermittent Loss of CMP or CKP. No misfire codes were set.

When this misfire would take place, the tachometer would bounce wildly from the true 1200-1400 RPMs to not true RPMs of 3000 to 3500.

When it was driven, it continued to have misfires along with the tach bouncing from real to not real readings. Due to this misfire issue, excessive throttle angle was needed to get enough speed for the vehicle to make the 1-2 shift. The shift was then late and firm. As a result, it becomes near impossible to get into any higher gears. Thus, the transmission malfunction complaint from the previous owner.

The code description suggests that the cam or crank sensor is dropping out, so I decided to use a lab scope to observe the signal.

At idle the crank signal looks fine (Figure 1), but also the vehicle runs fine and sets no codes at idle.

Shift-Pointers-Figure-1-Idle-Crank-Signal-1400
Figure 1.

When raising the RPM to the point of issue, the crank signal gains one extra pulse that is not evenly spaced with the rest (Figure 2).

Shift-Pointers-Figure-2-1400-Crank-Signal-1400
Figure 2.

So, the code is misleading as it is not a loss of CMP or CKP but a correlation problem. The odd thing is this extra pulse is not random. It occurs once every engine revolution. This indicates that it cannot be an intermittent electrical issue but must be a mechanical problem with the crank trigger wheel.  

On this vehicle the trigger wheel is the flex plate. By removing the converter shield, a visual inspection was preformed and revealed a crack in the flex plate (Figure 3).

Figure 3
Figure 3.

The crack must have been flexing open at speeds above idle and triggering the sensor. I bought a used flex plate from a local salvage yard for $8.

After replacement, all symptoms disappear, vehicle runs and drives well and sets no codes. When replacing the flex plate, I was surprised to see that externally the transmission case was clean and there were no leaks. I would have expected that a 23-year-old 4×4 truck with 283,000 miles would have mud, dirt and oil all over the transmission. I also noticed a sticker with a build date code on the converter: It was built in 2016. Since the fluid is clean and the transmission case is externally clean, I discovered that the transmission was rebuilt at that time. It seems that this rebuilt transmission was an attempt to resolve the late harsh shift complaint by someone who never saw the cracked flex plate.   

Read more columns from our Shift Pointers series here.

You May Also Like

Ford 8F35 maintenance tips: Planetary failure and no-pressure conditions

Our shop has had several vehicles come in with the Ford 8F35 transmission having planetary failure. Apparently, there was a run where the pinion needle bearings had a hardness problem (see Figure 1). Ford has a bulletin out (bulletin number 22-281), which provides a part number for this planetary assembly: the part number is JM5Z-7N473-C and

Figure 12.

Our shop has had several vehicles come in with the Ford 8F35 transmission having planetary failure. Apparently, there was a run where the pinion needle bearings had a hardness problem (see Figure 1).

Ford has a bulletin out (bulletin number 22-281), which provides a part number for this planetary assembly: the part number is JM5Z-7N473-C and costs about $160.

Don’t fear customer complaints about CVTs

Continuously Variable Transmissions, or CVTs, are more common than you think. Audi, Subaru, Nissan, Ford, GM and many other automakers use CVT transmissions in cars and SUVs. There is no way to avoid them. Chances are there is one in your shop right now. Related Articles – Back with force: ATSG is back in full

CVT-Transmission-2
Shift Pointers: A Chrysler 300 no-shift complaint

The case study has to do with a 2009 Chrysler 300 C 5.7L Nag1 RWD with 71,923 miles on it (see Figure 1, above). Related Articles – A guide to common GM, Ford and Nissan programming issues – Shift of the shaft: Diagnosing Chrysler 48RE manual shaft issues – Sometimes, a diagnostic code is all

A guide to common GM, Ford and Nissan programming issues

One of the most common complaints I hear from shops when trying to install a new GM TCM is, “The module will not communicate.” While that might be partially true, by design they won’t communicate until they are programmed. If programming fails, there will be an “E” code set which will help you get to

Shift of the shaft: Diagnosing Chrysler 48RE manual shaft issues

The TorqueFlite transmission has been around since mid-to-late 1950s. There have been many changes surrounding the manual shaft and rooster comb through the years. This transmission shaft controls the position of the manual valve that directs oil for the gear ranges, but it also is used for a Reverse light control as well as Park/Neutral

Other Posts

Jatco JF613E transmission quick reference material

For those working on the Jatco JR613E transmission, a widespread transmission with plenty of applications, the following should be a helpful guide. Related Articles – Complete the 2024 transmission shop survey for a chance to win a gift card – Think pink: Curtis Price strikes out on his own and has Liberty Transmission and Auto

Easy TH400, 4L80-E reverse servo setup: Craft your own tool

While not as sensitive as some shifting bands, the Reverse band adjustment on a TH400 or 4L80-E transmission is critical, and failure to get it right has tripped up even the best builders. There is nothing worse than getting the transmission installed, putting it in Reverse and then not going anywhere or having no engine

Spotting different 68RFE designs through the years to avoid issues

The Chrysler 68RFE has had several changes through the years. Its four-speed predecessor began with a noisy solenoid pack identified by a black colored pass-through case connector (seen in Figure 1).  Related Articles – Shift Pointers: Failures caused by incorrect tire sizes – Understanding lube flow control valves in Toyota/Lexus UA/UB80 transmissions – How reading

Shift Pointers: Failures caused by incorrect tire sizes

For years ATSG has produced a wide range of issues related to improper tire sizes on vehicles. Even under-inflated tires have been known to cause issues. Problems such as premature failure with an active 4WD transfer case will occur with incorrect tire sizes. Related Articles – Sometimes, you should sweat the small stuff – Fabricating

Shift-Pointers-Jan-Figure-1-1400