Back to square one: When a transmission replacement doesn’t fix the problem - Transmission Digest

Back to square one: When a transmission replacement doesn’t fix the problem

The subject of this article is a 2002 Ford Ranger with a 3.0L V6 engine and 5R44E transmission. There were 191,622 miles on the vehicle when it arrived at our shop. The owner said that the transmission was not shifting correctly and the OD lamp was flashing.

I performed the initial evaluation and road test, then scanned for any DTCs that were recorded. There was a series of ratio codes: P0731 (ratio error in first), P0733 (ratio error in third), P0734 (ratio error in fourth), and P0735 (ratio error stored in fifth). On my road test I experienced erratic shifting and there were flares (spin up) between shifts. The transmission fluid was in very poor condition and had a burnt odor to it. I also checked the battery and charging system. I found the alternator had AC ripple out of range (too high). The alternator was replaced and retested, and the ripple issue was corrected.

A replacement remanufactured transmission was recommended. The customer authorized the repairs, and we installed the transmission. However, during the final road test, the transmission started to shift erratically. The scanner data indicated that the solenoids were being cycled on and off. A movie of the road test was captured and analyzed once the vehicle was back at the shop. (See Figure 1.)

RR-August-FIG-1-1400
Figure 1.

After reviewing all the data, I concluded that there was a fault with the PCM. I could not find anything commanding the erratic shifts. I did a static test of the powers and grounds and all tested well. We let the customer know, and we installed and programmed a used replacement PCM and reset the PATS (passive anti-theft system). After an extended final road test, the vehicle was working properly and was delivered to the customer.

Our customer put about 190 miles on the Ranger, then returned to the shop, this time saying that the OD lamp was flashing and transmission was not shifting correctly. He said that it had to be driven 30-plus continuous miles before the lamp starts flashing. It seemed rather odd for it to take 30-plus continuous miles for the transmission to set a DTC. Regardless, we were back to square one.

I started down the highway and kept the vehicle at a steady speed. At mile 32, the torque converter clutch started slipping and code P0741 (TCC system, mechanical problem) set, and the OD lamp started flashing (See Figure 2).

RR-August-FIG-2-1400
Figure 2.

I decided to get off the highway at that point, and when I did, the transmission would barely pull itself and was slipping through every shift. I had to nurse it back to the workshop. I wasn’t sure I would make it without a tow.

The condition of the transmission had deteriorated so much that a replacement transmission had to be installed. The replacement transmission was not working much better, and it didn’t take long before the transmission began to shift oddly. When coming to a stop, it would go from fifth to first, and then taking off, it would shift first to fifth. There was no upshift to the next gear, and when slowing there was no downshifting to the next lower gear.

There had to be something wrong with this vehicle to set DTCs, cause erratic shifts and slip. I decided that a deep dive into this vehicle was required. I started with a line pressure and EPC pressure test. The actual gauge pressures were compared to the information on the scan tool.

The EPC pressure was much lower than what the scan tool was showing.

EPC 2

Since the EPC pressures did not match the scan tool data, I suspected that the used PCM I purchased was faulty. That’s the unfortunate risk we take when sourcing used controllers.

I replaced the PCM again, reprogramming and resetting PATS. The pressures were tested again, and this time the EPC pressures aligned with the scan tool data. The line pressures read near the specification. But it was too late for this transmission. I had driven it long enough to do damage to the clutches and bands. I replaced the transmission again.

On the road test for this new transmission, I noticed shift solenoids being commanded erratically and the DTCs returned almost immediately. A movie was taken of the road test and reviewed once I got back to the shop. Since I did not know what I needed to look at on the data PIDs, I kept all the PIDs available to capture. I could eliminate the PIDs I didn’t need and narrow the list down later. I found that when the case ground data PID went out of range (0.250 volts), the DTCs would set.

Take a look at Figure 3; that is a lot of voltage on a ground circuit. Looking at the case ground on the scan tool was not something I paid a lot of attention to, until now.

RR-August-FIG-3-1400
Figure 3.

In addition, matching the erratic case ground event to the cycling shift solenoids’ timing, I had some ammunition and a direction to go (See Figure 4).

RR-August-FIG-4-1400
Figure 4.

I scoped four out of the five grounds at the PCM. I was shocked to see the voltage on the grounds randomly spike as high as four volts. (See Figure 5).

RR-August-FIG-5-1400
Figure 5.

These spikes had no pattern and were very random. Since there are five separate grounds that spliced into one, I decided that I would make a jumper harness from an old Ford PCM harness so that I could bypass them for testing.
The five grounds at the PCM (pins 24, 51, 76, 77, 103) splice into a 10-gauge wire that goes under the intake plenum and into a bulkhead connector (C124), then to G108 at the radiator support. I suspected there was an issue with the C124 connector. The jumper harness would eliminate any issues along the way. I repinned the PCM connector with the jumper harness I’d made and ran straight to the battery negative terminal (See Figure 6).

RR-August-FIG-6-1400
Figure 6.

The scope pattern idling with all the accessories on looked much better. Even though there was some noise on the circuit, the average voltage was less than 0.1 volt (jumper wire and alligator clips). This road test went very well. No longer were there voltage spikes on the ground circuit; the shifts were smooth and on time; and the TCC slip was zero RPM. Take a look at Figure 7; it appeared that I’d found the problem.

RR-August-FIG-7-1400
Figure 7.

After returning from the road test, the jumper harness was made permanent. A 10-gauge wire was soldered onto the splice and a new crimp-type battery terminal was installed on the negative battery terminal. Once the harness was permanent and routed nicely, the Ranger was driven several more times for long distances. The scope pattern for the ground now was 0.025V to 0.07V. The Ranger was ready to give back to the customer. (Figures 8 and 9).

RR-August-FIG-8-1400
Figure 8.
RR-August-FIG-9-1400
Figure 9.

Hindsight is always 20/20 and looking back, the static voltage drop test with a DVOM on the ground was not enough to see these random spikes. I don’t always look at the ground PID on the scan data, so that was initially missed. Going forward, voltage and ground PIDs will be a part of data I look at going forward. This is how we learn to enhance the accuracy of our diagnoses.

Read more stories in our R&R Tech series here.

Brent Brown is a diagnostician at Certified Transmission’s shop in Gladstone, Missouri. When not diagnosing transmission problems on cars and trucks, one will likely find Brent spending time with his wife, three sons, and daughter. Brent enjoys reading and sketching in his free time along with tending to his Bonsai trees.

You May Also Like

Back with force: ATSG is back in full swing to educate the transmission industry

“Everywhere you turned, there was something amazing. It’s probably the coolest man cave I’ve ever been in,” says Wayne Colonna who, as president, heads up the technical team at the Automatic Transmission Service Group (ATSG). Wayne is describing the host venue for his company’s inaugural 2024 seminar that was held at the John Force Racing

“Everywhere you turned, there was something amazing. It’s probably the coolest man cave I’ve ever been in,” says Wayne Colonna who, as president, heads up the technical team at the Automatic Transmission Service Group (ATSG). Wayne is describing the host venue for his company’s inaugural 2024 seminar that was held at the John Force Racing facility and museum in the Los Angeles suburb of Yorba Linda, California. Transtar’s Orange, CA branch served as the presenting host for the event.

A guide to common GM, Ford and Nissan programming issues

One of the most common complaints I hear from shops when trying to install a new GM TCM is, “The module will not communicate.” While that might be partially true, by design they won’t communicate until they are programmed. If programming fails, there will be an “E” code set which will help you get to

Going the extra mile: Proving your transmission repair suspicions

A 2003 Honda Pilot with a five-speed three-shaft transmission came into our shop with a customer concern that the vehicle had no power, and the “D” light was flashing. I first did a scan for codes to see what it came up with, and the scan tool returned four DTCs: P1298 (ELD voltage high), P0135 (H02S

RRfeature-1400
Hidden problems: Three tales of electrical issues

In this article, I will discuss some vehicles with electrical issues. These issues were previously addressed by a different shop/tech, but the improper or incomplete repair resulted in these hidden problems that would appear later. Related Articles – Sometimes, a diagnostic code is all you need – 10L80 and 10R80 pump gear differences – Top

How reading through service bulletins can turn a technician into the customer’s hero

Over the last 28 years of being a technician, I have developed the habit of checking for and reading technical service bulletins at the forefront of the diagnostic process, especially when an unfamiliar vehicle exhibiting blatant or straightforward concerns comes into the shop. I have found many valuable nuggets of information while reading over these

Other Posts

Jatco JF613E transmission quick reference material

For those working on the Jatco JR613E transmission, a widespread transmission with plenty of applications, the following should be a helpful guide. Related Articles – Complete the 2024 transmission shop survey for a chance to win a gift card – Think pink: Curtis Price strikes out on his own and has Liberty Transmission and Auto

Complete the 2024 transmission shop survey for a chance to win a gift card

Every year, Transmission Digest conducts the Retail Shop Survey. This survey will take five minutes or less. The results of this survey will appear in the March edition of our Powertrain Bulletin email newsletter, and should serve as a valuable benchmark for your business. Your responses will be kept confidential and reported only in the

Think pink: Curtis Price strikes out on his own and has Liberty Transmission and Auto Care stand out from the crowd

In 2018, Curtis Price, at 43 years old, found himself at a crossroads in his career in the transmission industry: unsure whether he could move up in the family business where he had worked for 20 years, or whether he should start his own. At the time he was working at Price’s Transmission in Virginia

Liberty-Transmission
Easy TH400, 4L80-E reverse servo setup: Craft your own tool

While not as sensitive as some shifting bands, the Reverse band adjustment on a TH400 or 4L80-E transmission is critical, and failure to get it right has tripped up even the best builders. There is nothing worse than getting the transmission installed, putting it in Reverse and then not going anywhere or having no engine